I think that's totally valid. I mean, I think that you have to let people have their reactions, and if you want to or don't want to read them that's cool. It's more the making fun of other people's reactions, or condemning them for it, that is uncool. A ton of folks were really mean to Alison when she was sad about Sirius and I really don't like seeing that sort of behaviour at all.

I know people who liked OotP and I think that's fine; I didn't enjoy it but I'm hoping that I'll enjoy HBP more.